Card testing fraud is a common form of credit card fraud in which fraudsters verify the usability of stolen credit card numbers. Typically, fraudsters carry out a series of small transactions across multiple websites. These microtransactions often go unnoticed by cardholders and fraud detection systems because the latter tend to focus on large or unusual spending patterns. Fraudsters use these test transactions to confirm whether the card is still active, whether it has not been flagged or canceled due to theft, and whether it has sufficient credit available for purchases.
This type of fraud exploits legitimate transaction processes to avoid detection. Fraudsters often target websites that process large volumes of small payments, since these transactions are less likely to trigger alerts. Once a card passes the initial “test” phase and is confirmed valid, its value to fraudsters increases significantly. They may use the card for larger unauthorized purchases or sell the verified details on illegal markets.
According to a Juniper Research report, global e-commerce fraud was projected to cost businesses more than $48 billion in 2023. The simplicity of card testing—requiring only a list of stolen card numbers and internet access—makes it a preferred method among cybercriminals. Because these transactions are digital, they can be executed anywhere, making enforcement difficult and creating greater challenges for businesses and financial institutions in protecting customer financial data. Below is what businesses need to know about this type of fraud and how they can protect themselves.
How Does Card Testing Fraud Work?
The process of card testing fraud is relatively straightforward. Fraudsters obtain stolen card numbers, test them for validity, and then use them. Here’s a detailed breakdown:
Fraudsters obtain stolen card numbers: The process begins when fraudsters acquire stolen credit card data. They may obtain it through data breaches, phishing schemes, or by purchasing card details on dark web markets. Once they have the numbers, they move to the testing phase.
They test the cards: The testing phase usually involves conducting small transactions on multiple websites. These transactions often bypass traditional fraud detection mechanisms since such systems mainly focus on large or suspicious purchases. Fraudsters typically choose sites that process microtransactions, such as digital service platforms or donation pages, where fraud controls are weaker.
They confirm whether cards are valid: The main goal is to verify that the card is still active and has not been reported lost or stolen. Fraudsters monitor whether their small transactions succeed. If approved, the card is considered valid. In cases where websites don’t strictly verify billing addresses or other details, testing becomes even easier.
They use validated cards for fraudulent purchases: Once a card is confirmed valid, it gains higher value. Fraudsters may confidently conduct larger unauthorized purchases themselves or sell the validated card data to others. Verified card numbers are in high demand on illegal markets.
This technique is widespread because of its simplicity and the borderless nature of online transactions. Businesses and financial institutions must take proactive measures, implementing advanced monitoring and strategic defenses to detect and prevent such fraud in order to protect customers and maintain trust.
How Card Testing Fraud Affects Businesses and Customers
Card testing fraud has consequences for both businesses and customers. While the impact on victims may seem obvious, here’s a breakdown of where the damage is often most severe:
Impact on businesses
-
Financial loss: Unauthorized transactions can result in direct financial loss. Businesses are often liable for chargebacks when customers dispute fraudulent charges.
-
Increased operational costs: Managing fraud cases requires significant resources, driving up operational costs. Additionally, maintaining advanced fraud detection systems demands financial investment.
-
Reputation damage: Frequent fraud incidents harm business reputation. Declining customer trust may lead to reduced sales and customer attrition.
-
Stricter scrutiny from issuers and processors: High fraud rates can result in stricter monitoring by credit card issuers and payment processors, potentially leading to higher processing fees or even loss of card payment privileges.
Impact on customers
-
Financial inconvenience: Victims must spend time and effort resolving disputes and replacing compromised cards. Although customers typically aren’t held liable for fraudulent charges, the resolution process can be burdensome.
-
Privacy concerns: Discovering that one’s card details have been stolen often raises concerns about personal privacy and financial security.
-
Risk of larger losses: While card testing usually involves small transactions, it often precedes larger unauthorized purchases or resale of the card details to other criminals.
-
Credit score impact: In some cases, prolonged undetected fraud can affect credit scores, and correcting such issues may take a long time.
Signs of Card Testing Fraud Attacks
Recognizing and responding to card testing attacks is critical for businesses to protect themselves and their customers. Awareness of warning signs and effective monitoring systems are key. Common indicators include:
-
Multiple small transactions: A sudden cluster of low-value transactions in a short timeframe is a strong indicator of card testing.
-
Use of multiple cards: Attempts to process transactions with numerous different card numbers from the same IP address or device often signal fraud.
-
High volume of declined transactions: Frequent failed attempts are typical in card testing, as fraudsters often use expired or invalid numbers.
-
Inconsistent billing information: Discrepancies between provided billing details and actual cardholder data may indicate fraudulent activity.
Detecting these signs and implementing proper monitoring can help businesses defend against attacks, protecting both revenue and customer trust.
How to Protect Your Business from Card Testing Fraud
Businesses can protect themselves by combining effective security measures, advanced tools, and best practices in payment processing. The goal is to identify and mitigate fraud while maintaining a smooth experience for legitimate customers.
Effective security measures and tools
-
Use Address Verification Service (AVS): AVS compares the billing address provided by the user with the one on file with the card issuer, flagging potential fraud when inconsistencies appear.
-
Implement Card Verification Value (CVV) checks: Requiring CVV codes helps confirm that the purchaser physically possesses the card, reducing risk when stolen numbers are used online.
-
Set transaction limits: Restrict the number or total value of transactions allowed per card within a set timeframe to limit repeated fraud attempts.
-
Adopt advanced fraud detection tools: Use machine learning and AI to analyze transaction patterns and detect anomalies consistent with card testing.
-
Enable multi-factor authentication: For suspicious transactions, add extra layers of identity verification to block fraud attempts.
Best practices in payment processing
-
Monitor and analyze transaction patterns: Regularly review transaction data to identify card testing patterns, such as clusters of low-value charges.
-
Regularly update and upgrade security systems: Keep security protocols and software up to date to stay ahead of evolving fraud tactics.
-
Employee training: Ensure staff can recognize signs of card testing and respond appropriately.
-
Comply with PCI DSS standards: Following Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards is essential for secure payment processing.
-
Transparent customer communication: Keep customers informed about security measures and encourage them to report suspicious activity.
Early detection through monitoring systems
Comprehensive monitoring systems are vital for detecting card testing at an early stage. These systems should:
-
Analyze transaction patterns for rapid small-charge activity.
-
Flag suspicious behavior such as multiple declines or mismatched billing details.
-
Issue real-time alerts for immediate action against potential fraud.
-
Allow customization of detection parameters based on specific business models.
-
Integrate with fraud prevention tools like CVV and AVS checks for stronger defense.
By combining these strategies, businesses can create a secure environment to deter card testing fraud. Remaining vigilant and adapting to emerging threats helps protect both businesses and customers.
How to Respond to Card Testing Fraud Attacks
Responding effectively to suspected card testing incidents is crucial for minimizing losses and recovering quickly. Businesses should follow clear steps when such activity is detected.
Steps to take when fraud is detected
-
Immediately review and freeze transactions: As soon as card testing is suspected, review related transactions and halt any that appear fraudulent.
-
Increase verification for suspicious transactions: If certain charges raise concerns but are not yet confirmed as fraud, implement enhanced checks, such as contacting customers directly or requiring additional verification.
-
Analyze transaction patterns: Conduct a full analysis of suspicious activity to understand the scope of the attack and uncover system weaknesses.
-
Adjust fraud detection parameters: Based on findings, fine-tune detection settings—for example, tightening transaction limits or modifying alert triggers.
Reporting and recovery measures
-
Notify financial institutions and processors: Inform banks and payment partners immediately, enabling them to help monitor and mitigate further fraudulent activity.
-
Report to law enforcement: Large-scale fraud cases should be reported to authorities, who may launch investigations to track perpetrators.
-
Work with cybersecurity experts: For complex attacks or suspected system vulnerabilities, consulting professionals helps identify methods used and prevent recurrence.
-
Communicate with affected customers: Be transparent with customers. Inform them of the incident and suggest protective steps, such as monitoring credit reports or requesting card replacements.
-
Review and strengthen defenses: Afterward, conduct a thorough review of security measures. Improvements may include updating software, adjusting protocols, or providing additional staff training.
-
Learn and adapt: Treat each incident as a learning opportunity. Evaluate what happened, what worked in the response, and what needs improvement. Update strategies to be better prepared against future threats.